In a courtroom, justice can get trumped by the calendar.
The Colorado Supreme Court recently reminded us that “fair” and “legal” are rarely the same thing. In Mostellar v. City of Colorado Springs, a woman was injured and did what most people do: she tried to hold the responsible party accountable. She followed the rules as she understood them, but she missed a technical deadline because the government didn’t tell her who was actually liable until it was too late.
Long story short: the law doesn’t care if you’re right if you miss a critical deadline.
Under the Colorado Governmental Immunity Act, you have exactly 182 days to tell a public entity you intend to sue them. It is a strict window. Mostellar didn’t know the City of Colorado Springs was a potential defendant until after those six months passed. She only found out because another city agency eventually disclosed an intergovernmental agreement that shifted liability.
The court admitted this outcome may seem “harsh and inequitable”. They even noted that while the plaintiff acted in good faith, the government of Manitou Springs, where the injury occurred, delayed disclosing the information that would have allowed her to file on time.
The court dismissed her case anyway. It found that there were alternative ways to identify Colorado Spring’s liability and that Colorado Springs did not mislead Mostellar in any way or prevent her from filing timely.
When a court says its hands are tied, it’s usually because the legislature held the rope.
The court’s reasoning was plain: the statute is the statute. They ruled that the notice period starts on the day of the injury, regardless of whether the victim has the information needed to identify the correct defendant. In their view, strict compliance with the letter of the law outweighs a corrective effort to remedy an injustice.
What’s really happening here? Public entities use these technicalities as armor; the rules are rigid by design. Sometimes, particularly when dealing with a government entity as a defendant, the most dangerous part of a claim isn’t the injury itself: it’s the clock.
Responsibility shouldn’t be a shell game. No plaintiff wants to see their clear injury resulting in zero accountability.
This is where a capable personal injury attorney earns their keep. In the Mostellar case, the truth about who was liable was buried in an intergovernmental agreement that the government didn’t disclose until the deadline had already passed. A skilled lawyer doesn’t wait for the government to be transparent. They know how to hunt for every potential defendant and peel back the layers of hidden liability structures before the clock runs out.


